Some argue that the Glock 23 is the only handgun that you will ever need. A few reasons that make the Glock 23 that effective are the lightweight polymer frame, modular design, and incredible versatility. As a lightweight and relatively small firearm, the Glock 23 is suitable for carrying concealed. The modular design makes it easy to customize and easy to repair — something that does not often happen.
Finding a forever holster for your Glock 23 can be a little overwhelming because of the sheer number of holster options on the market. Because the Glock 23 and Glock 19 are the same dimensions, there are plenty of holsters available. But do not worry, because that is where I come in! I will analyse the options available and pick my top recommended holster!
Click here for more Glock holster options
Quick Answer – What Is The Best Holster For Glock 23 Handguns
Time is money! So let’s get straight to the point. If you want a solid holster for your G23, I recommend the following holsters:
- The best OWB holster: 1791 GUNLEATHER XDS Thumb Break Holster
- The best IWB holster: Relentless Tactical Holster
- The best CCW holster: ComfortTac Ultimate Belly Band Holster
The Best OWB Holster For Glock 23 Handguns
With the size and calibre of the G23, chances are you are looking for a Outside-The-Waistband (OWB) holster. So what is the best OWB holster for Glock 23 handguns? I list a few of the top rated OWB holsters that fit the G23 below.
Bedone
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
Everyone prefers a different firearm retention level. Unlike leather or kydex holsters that are molded to a specific firearm, this holster is constructed from a polymer that allows for a looser fit. Even though the Glock 23 does not have a tight fit, this holster may not be compatible with aftermarket sights or lasers.
When your Glock 23 is returned to the holster, you will hear an audible click to let you know it is positioned correctly. This locking system is disengaged with the index finger. There are some who argue that this system is a safety hazard. If you are comfortable with an index-finger release button, this Bedone holster might be right for your Glock 23. Even with the release button, this holster allows for a very fast draw. To help with that fast draw, this holster features cant angle adjustment with an included key.
On some body types, the firearm is angled awkwardly away from the body. The only way to find out if that will be true for you is to try wearing this holster. Although this holster is available at an affordable price point, it is well-made and an excellent choice if you want to avoid leather or nylon holsters.
Bedone Features at a Glance:
- Material: Polymer
- Holster Style: Outside the waistband, paddle
- Retention Device: Index finger button
- Made in the United States: No
1791 Gunleather
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
If a classic leather holster is your style, this 1791 Gunleather holster might just be the perfect one for you. Both color options feature sturdy double stitching, heavy leather, and excellent craftsmanship. The biggest issue this holster faces is a lengthy conditioning period. Before this break-in period, you will have an extremely snug fit. Because of the thumb retention strap, the out-of-the-box fit is so tight it can be difficult to wedge the firearm inside.
The more aggressively you condition this holster, the looser firearm fit you will have. However, that takes time. Even with the thumb retention strap, it only takes a little practice to develop a fast draw. While not as adjustable as kydex or polymer holsters, this leather holster does include two different cant angles.
If you have beavertail grips, lasers, or other aftermarket attachments, this holster may be too tight for your Glock 23. However, if you are comfortable with a long break-in period and your firearm does not have any aftermarket accessories, this holster will last as long as your Glock. Because this holster is worn over the waistband, it is not the most suitable way to carry concealed. Of course, that depends on your wardrobe. If you value handmade excellence and a signature leather style, this is the best owb holster for Glock 23 handguns.
1791 Gunleather Features at a Glance:
- Material: Leather
- Holster Style: Outside the waistband, belt-loops
- Retention Device: Thumb-break retention strap
- Made in the United States: Assembled in the United States after being processed in Mexico
Safariland
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
When it comes to holsters with thumb-button retention devices, Safariland is an industry leader. While the thumb button does slow your draw down a little, it is easy to learn and becomes second nature after some practice. When returning your Glock 23 to the holster, this holster will click to let you know the locking system has been engaged.
Because it is constructed from a proprietary polymer, this holster does not take time to condition. However, it may leave slight marks on your firearm’s finish because it does not have a lining. Making it more comfortable to wear for long periods of time, the polymer also means that this holster is lighter than other holster materials.
Although the listing shows this holster is compatible with concealed carry, it is still worn outside the waistband, which makes it less suitable for concealed carrying than holsters worn inside the waistband. Of course, even holsters worn outside the waistband are concealable under bulky clothes. Unlike many Glock 23 holsters, this Safariland holster does include options to make it compatible with your Glock’s aftermarket accessories. The Safariland Glock 23 holster is a durably constructed holster designed with safety in mind.
Safariland Features at a Glance:
- Material: Polymer
- Holster Style: Outside the waistband, paddle or belt loop
- Retention Device: Thumb button
- Made in the United States: Yes
Blackhawk Serpa
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
The first point of discussion for the Blackhawk Serpa always seems to be the index-finger release button. Depending on your drawing habits, the index-finger release button may be either a significant safety issue or a nonissue altogether. If you put in a good amount of practice drawing, the odds of an accidental discharge get lower. Beyond the potential safety issues attached to the Blackhawk Serpa, this is a reliable holster.
Each holster arrives with a kit to mount either on the belt loops or as a paddle. This lets you figure out the best way to carry it on your person. Although the firearm retention screw does offer adjustment options, your Glock 23 may rattle as you move. The firearm is locked into place and will not fall out of the holster. However, the rattling can lead to wear on your Glock 23 as well as undermining any attempt to carry concealed.
There are some easy modifications that can stop that rattling, but not everyone is comfortable modifying a holster. For long periods of time, the Blackhawk Serpa is comfortable but does get a little heavy. It is not suitable for concealed carry unless you usually wear loose or bulky clothes. If you are willing to put some practice hours into drawing from this holster, it is a reliable holster for your Glock 23.
Blackhawk Serpa Features at a Glance:
- Material: Polymer
- Holster Style: Outside the waistband, belt loop or paddle
- Retention Device: Index-finger button
- Made in the United States: Yes
The Best IWB Holster For Glock 23 Handguns
Thanks to its compact design, Inside-The-Waistband (IWB) holsters are an option if you are looking for a holster to fit your G23. Below I list some great options you can consider.
Relentless Tactical
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
Comfort is one of the most important concerns for holsters worn inside the waistband. Made from high-quality leather, Relentless Tactical’s holster stays comfortable all day long. That includes driving and even heavy physical activity. If you carry with the holster directly against your skin, parts of the leather might be irritating at first. It does take a break-in period to fit your Glock 23 specifically.
Because leather is malleable and this holster is not yet molded to any specific firearm, this holster will work with certain aftermarket accessories. The leather quality is not on par with top-tier leather holsters, but this holster’s price point is significantly less than top-tier holsters. Because each holster is handmade in the United States, the stitching quality is excellent. If you find an issue with the quality or stitching, Relentless Tactical’s customer service team will work to make it right.
There is no retention device except how snugly the Glock 23 fits into the holster. You will have a faster draw, but does mean one less layer of security. Overall, this Relentless Tactical holster is a comfortable, affordable, and attractive way to carry your Glock 23 concealed.
Relentless Tactical Features at a Glance:
- Material: Leather, steel belt clip
- Holster Style: Inside the waistband, belt clip
- Retention Device: None
- Made in the United States: Yes
Alien Gear
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
Alien Gear is renowned for their high quality hybrid-style holsters. This offering uses a neoprene backing next to the skin and a molded polymer to secure the firearm. Because it wicks sweat away from the skin, neoprene is one of the most comfortable holster materials.
If leather or kydex sound painful against your skin, a hybrid holster might be right for you. The steel core gives stability while the polymer provides some flexibility without adding much weight. Although plastic, the belt clips aggressively grip the belt. This is good in that an assailant would be unable to remove the belt, but it also means that it will be difficult for you to remove the holster.
If you plan on putting it on and removing it frequently, the aggressive belt clips might be a deterrent. However, once this holster is on, it is intensely comfortable for all day use. Firearm retention, cant angle, and ride height are all adjustable to give you a customized holster experience. This lets you figure out exactly where it needs to be for optimal concealment. The biggest problem for this holster is that the screws come loose. A quick application of a screw-locking product can fix that.
Alien Gear Features at a Glance:
- Material: Neoprene, steel, polymer, and plastic belt clips
- Holster Style: Inside the waistband, belt clips
- Retention Device: Retention screw
- Made in the United States: Yes
Houston
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
Plenty of cushioning and a pliable eco-leather material make this holster the ultimate comfort holster. Even the inside is lined in a pseudo-suede material for your firearm’s comfort. This holster is handmade and showcases good-quality stitching. Because no part of this holster is molded, it can fit multiple firearms of similar dimensions. It also means some aftermarket accessories will fit.
However, the lack of molding and lack of retention device mean that the only measure keeping your Glock 23 inside this holster is the pressure your pants put on the holster. If you engage in a great deal of heavy physical activity, there is a chance your Glock 23 will not stay in this holster.
However, if you do lots of sitting or standing, this holster may be just right for comfortable concealed carrying. Even if you are not able to use it as your everyday carry, you may be able to use this holster as a backup because it is not specific to the Glock 23.
Houston Features at a Glance:
- Material: Eco-leather, pseudo-suede lining, metal belt clips
- Holster Style: Inside the waistband, belt clips
- Retention Device: None
- Made in the United States: Designed in the United States, assembled in Argentina
The Best CCW Holster For Glock 23 Handguns
Concealed carry is an option that a lot of folks will be looking for. Below I list two CCW options for you – an ankle holster as well as a belly holster.
AIKATE
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
If you want a really fast draw, an ankle holster is probably not the best choice. However, this AIKATE holster is the best holster for Glock 23 owners who need an alternative way to carry concealed. Neoprene and plenty of padding make it a very comfortable choice while the thumb-break retention strap keeps your Glock 23 securely in place.
The hook and loop fabric fasteners keep this holster snug against your leg even through heavy physical activity such as running. These fabric fasteners do wear out after a few years, but that is to be expected at this price point. Depending on your ankle and how your pants fit, the handgun’s outline may be visible.
This holster is not specific to the Glock 23 — it can hold a variety of firearms. Another bonus is the pouch for an extra magazine, pepper spray, or even a flashlight. Whether you are looking for a holster to carry every day or for a backup, the AIKATE ankle holster is a dependable way to carry your Glock 23.
AIKATE Features at a Glance:
- Material: Neoprene
- Holster Style: Ankle
- Retention Device: Thumb-break snap
- Made in the United States: No
ComfortTac
>>Click on Image To The Check Price on Amazon<<
For those who need to carry while wearing sweatpants or athletic shorts, the ComfortTac belly band offers a concealed carry option that does not require a belt. While it takes some time to get used to the weight of your firearm, this holster is comfortable enough to wear all day.
Drawing from a belly band will never be as fast as drawing from more traditional holsters, but this holster gives you the flexibility to forgo a belt. This holster works well both for those with slight builds and those with larger builds. You will not have to switch up your wardrobe to carry concealed.
It may take some experimentation to figure out exactly where on your abdomen this belly band needs to live to minimize firearm visibility. The ComfortTac belly band holster is well-constructed from high-quality materials. It may not last as long as a leather holster, but it offers significantly more versatility.
ComfortTac Features at a Glance:
- Material: Neoprene, elastic, and plastic trigger guard
- Holster Style: Belly band
- Retention Device: Thumb-break retention strap
- Made in the United States: Yes
Best Affordable Holster: ComfortTac
Because this holster is comfortable and versatile, it is the best holster for Glock 23 handguns at an affordable price point. It conceals your firearm and you do not even have to wear pants with a belt.
- Our belly band holster is available in right- and left-hand draw; designed for firearms of various sizes, including subcompact, compact, and full-size pistols and revolvers
Best Value for Money: Relentless Tactical
Relentless Tactical makes a leather holster that is absolutely gorgeous when it is not concealing your Glock 23. The craftsmanship is excellent, but, as with most handmade products, there can be defects. The customer service team at Relentless Tactical works to rectify any problems.
- This Is The Perfect Concealed Carry Holster For Your Glock! It Fits Glock 19 / 19X / 23 / 32 | Glock 17 / 17L / 22 / 31 / 40 | Glock 26 / 27 / 33 | Glock 43 / 43x | Glock 45. This holster fits virtually all Standard, Compact and Sub-Compact Glocks
Best Overall Value: 1791 Gunleather
Nothing can replace exquisite craftsmanship. This is the best owb holster for Glock 23 owners who are able to carry without concealing.
- CUSTOM FIT: Compatible for Glock 17,19,22,23,25,26,27,28,29,30,32,33 // S&W MP40, MP Shield, 5903 // Sig Sauer P225, P228, P229 // CZ P08 // FNS-9, FNX-9 // Honor Defense Fist, HG9CLS, HG9SC (COMPLETE LIST OF SIZE & CALIBER BELOW...)
